FPI Overnight Brief: February 25, 2010
The War
The C.I.A. and its Pakistani counterpart, the Directorate of Inter-Services Intelligence, have a long and often tormented relationship. And even now, they are moving warily toward conflicting goals, with each maneuvering to protect its influence after the shooting stops in Afghanistan. Yet interviews in recent days show how they are working together on tactical operations, and how far the C.I.A. has extended its extraordinary secret war beyond the mountainous tribal belt and deep into Pakistan’s sprawling cities. Beyond the capture of Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, C.I.A. operatives working with the ISI have carried out dozens of raids throughout Pakistan over the past year, working from bases in the cities of Quetta, Peshawar and elsewhere, according to Pakistani security officials. The raids often come after electronic intercepts by American spy satellites, or tips from Pakistani informants — and the spies from the two countries then sometimes drive in the same car to pick up their quarry. Sometimes the teams go on lengthy reconnaissance missions, with the ISI operatives packing sunscreen and neon glow sticks that allow them to identify their positions at night…The C.I.A.’s drone campaign in Pakistan is well known, which is striking given that this is a covert war. But these on-the-ground activities have been shrouded in secrecy because the Pakistani government has feared the public backlash against the close relationship with the Americans. – New York Times
Editorial: We fear the Dutch decision
could provide cover for wavering politicians elsewhere — Germany, for example,
or Canada, which is now scheduled to pull out its troops at the end of 2011.
Europe’s leaders need to tell themselves — and their voters — the truth. The
war in Afghanistan is not just about America’s security. It, too, is about
denying sanctuaries to Al Qaeda, which has also carried out deadly terrorist
attacks in Europe. NATO is stronger when it stands together. The Netherlands
weakens itself and all of its allies by choosing to stand alone. -New
York Times
Pakistan offered to hand over a detained senior Taliban leader to Afghan authorities, as officials from the two nations discussed broadening their cooperation in fighting the insurgency. Pakistan's Interior Minister Rehman Malik said after a meeting here with his Afghan counterpart, Mohammed Hanif Atmar, that Islamabad was expecting a formal request from Kabul to extradite Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, the Afghan Taliban's operations chief. "When we receive a formal request from the Afghan government, we will honor it," Mr. Malik said Wednesday. – Wall Street Journal
Pakistan has arrested
nearly half of the Afghanistan Taliban’s leadership in recent days, Pakistani
officials told the Monitor Wednesday, dealing what could be a crucial blow to
the insurgent movement. In total, seven of the insurgent group’s
15-member leadership council, thought to be based in Quetta, Pakistan,
including the head of military operations, have been apprehended in the past
week, according to Pakistani intelligence officials. Western and Pakistani
media had previously reported the arrest of three of the 15, but this is the
first confirmation of the wider scale of the Pakistan crackdown on the Taliban
leadership, something the US has sought. – Christian
Science Monitor
Andrew Exum writes: [C]ommanders recognize a balance must be struck between expected effects and the risks taken by troops. It may well be that after years of downplaying the strategic effects of collateral damage and civilian casualties, the U.S. military and its allies have now effectively overcorrected and are too reticent to use overwhelming firepower even when warranted… Officers have always been required to balance the needs of the mission with the welfare of the troops, and in the case of Afghanistan, the short-term dangers endured by our troops contribute to both the long-term prospects of the mission—as well as the eventual homecoming of U.S. and allied soldiers from Afghanistan. – The Daily Beast
Afghanistan
A blizzard of bank notes is flying out of Afghanistan -- often in full view of customs officers at the Kabul airport -- as part of a cash exodus that is confounding U.S. officials and raising concerns about the money's origin. The cash, estimated to total well over $1 billion a year, flows mostly to the Persian Gulf emirate of Dubai, where many wealthy Afghans now park their families and funds, according to U.S. and Afghan officials. So long as departing cash is declared at the airport here, its transfer is legal. But at a time when the United States and its allies are spending billions of dollars to prop up the fragile government of President Hamid Karzai, the volume of the outflow has stirred concerns that funds have been diverted from aid…"All this money magically appears from nowhere," said a U.S. official who monitors Afghanistan's growing role as a hub for cash transfers to Dubai, which has six flights a day to and from Kabul. – Washington Post
Pakistan
The Pakistani government plans to change its blasphemy law to check its misuse by extremist groups, officials said on Thursday. The law, which carries the death penalty for insulting Islam or its prophet, is a highly sensitive issue in Pakistan, which is more than 95 percent Muslim. Previous governments have failed to reform the law because of opposition from powerful hard-line Islamic groups. Liberal and secular groups have called for the repeal of the blasphemy law altogether, which they say discriminates against religious minorities. However, the U.S.-allied government of President Asif Ali Zardari, which is fighting an Islamist insurgency, says it plans to reform the law instead. "We are holding consultative meetings with representatives of minorities and political parties, as well as with Muslim clerics," Minister for Religious Affairs Shahbaz Bhatti told Reuters. "Some elements misuse the law to create violence and disharmony in society. To stop that misuse, we are proposing legislation."…Blasphemy convictions are common in Pakistan, although the death sentence has never been carried out. Most convictions are thrown out on appeal or because of lack of evidence. However, angry mobs have killed many people, mostly members of religious minorities. - Reuters
South Asia
The Obama administration is sharply expanding American weapons transfers to both India and Pakistan, longtime rivals about to sit down for peace talks Thursday. The U.S. has sought to remain neutral in the thorny relationship between the nuclear-armed neighbors. But Washington hasn't been shy about pursuing weapons deals in the region, which officials say will lead to closer ties with each country while creating new opportunities for American defense firms. The U.S. has made billions of dollars in weapons deals with India, which is in the midst of a five-year, $50 billion push to modernize its military. At the same time, American military aid to Pakistan stands to nearly double next year, allowing Islamabad to acquire more U.S.-made helicopters, night-vision goggles and other military equipment. The aid has made it easier for Pakistan to ramp up its fight against militants on the Afghan border, as the U.S. tries to convince Islamabad that its biggest security threat is within the country, not in India. – Wall Street Journal
At a critical moment across the region, senior officials from India and Pakistan held their first official talks since the 2008 Mumbai attacks on Thursday, with the United States hoping that even a modest improvement in relations could help the broader American military effort in Pakistan and Afghanistan. The Indian foreign secretary, Nirupama Rao, and his Pakistani counterpart, Salman Bashir, met amid signs of some flexibility. As Mr. Bashir arrived in New Delhi, India announced that his schedule on Thursday would be broader than previously announced. Besides meeting with Mr. Rao, Mr. Bashir will also meet with India’s minister of external affairs, S. M. Krishna, and the country’s national security adviser, the newly appointed Shivshankar Menon. Yet achieving even modest progress is likely to prove a challenge, analysts say. In advance of Thursday’s discussions, the nuclear-armed neighbors have squabbled over what would be discussed. India wants the agenda to focus on terrorism, while Pakistan wants to resume talks that broke off after the November 2008 attacks in Mumbai, India, by militants trained in Pakistan. – New York Times
Aproova Shah writes: It’s difficult to see how either side will budge from these hardened stances. Yet the Obama team—who doesn’t appear to have put too much thought into the possible outcomes of this process —just seems to be happy that the sides are talking, regardless of the repercussions. As one senior administration official has said, “the bar is pretty low.”But here’s where ostensibly harmless dialogue could become tragic. What if, during or following the talks, there’s another attack in India on the scale of Mumbai or worse? Based on past experience, such as following the Indian Parliament shootings in 2001 and Mumbai in 2008, India would immediately cut off the talks and begin preparing for military retaliation. Having already pursued direct diplomatic engagement, there would be no further, non-military step for India to take. And while it was the United States that pushed India to restrain itself in 2001 and 2008, the Obama administration appears to have lost much of the leverage and goodwill that reached historic highs under the Bush administration. Does the Obama team really think that its massive aid packages to Pakistan and acquiescence to China are ignored in New Delhi? – The Enterprise
Central Asia
An adviser to former president Bill Clinton intervened in 2005 to help win Kazakh approval of a uranium mining deal benefiting a major donor to the Clinton Foundation, according to a video statement made by the former chief of Kazakhstan's state nuclear firm. The executive, Mukhtar Dzhakishev, who was arrested last year on corruption charges that he has denied, described the deal as "a financing mechanism of the Democratic Party" and said a Clinton adviser named Tim Phillips championed it in meetings with him and other officials. The statement is the first confirmation by a Kazakh official that a member of Clinton's staff lobbied the government on behalf of Canadian mining financier Frank Giustra, who purchased stakes in three Kazakh uranium deposits that he later sold for a huge profit. – Washington Post
The desolate fields [of Kazakhstan] sit above one of the world's largest deposits of uranium, and with nuclear energy in a renaissance, a rough-and-tumble battle is underway for access to them. The race echoes the geopolitical jockeying to control Central Asia's rich reserves of oil and natural gas -- a variation on Rudyard Kipling's Great Game, complete with corporate intrigue, a disgraced spy chief and an alleged plot by the Kremlin to keep this former Soviet republic under its thumb. Leading energy and mining firms from Russia, China, Japan, France and Canada have already invested billions here. Kazakhstan, meanwhile, is seeking to leverage its ore into a larger role in the global nuclear industry and has taken a stake in the U.S.-based nuclear giant Westinghouse. – Washington Post
Defense
In an effort to grow the U.S. Navy faster than planned, one key lawmaker has proposed forcing the service to hold off taking ships out of service until more are ready to replace them. "I want to put you on notice," Rep. Gene Taylor, D-Miss., told the Navy's top officials Feb. 24. "Decommissioning 10 ships this year is unacceptable. "It is my intention that for every three ships that are commissioned, we give permission to decommission two. We need to stop the bleeding this year." Of the 10 ships the Navy is planning to remove from service in fiscal 2011, three are frigates, three are amphibious ships, three are civilian-manned ammunition ships and one is a nuclear submarine. Only about five ships are planned to enter service in the same time frame. – Defense News
Josh Rogin reports: Secretary of State
Hillary Clinton on Wednesday announced plans to reorganize the "T"
bureau at the State Department, seeking to roll back changes made by former
Under Secretary John Bolton during George W. Bush's presidency. "We
are undertaking a focused reorganization of the Bureau of
International Security and Nonproliferation and the Bureau of Verification,
Compliance, and Implementation," Clinton wrote in
a letter to T bureau staff. "The goals of this reorganization are to
realign the missions of the VCI and ISN bureaus to better leverage their
support for key national security objectives and to create dedicated
organizational advocates for arms control and verification and compliance, and
nonproliferation." Under Secretary of State for Arms Control Ellen
Tauscher, who leads the T bureau, explained the rationale in a town-hall
meeting with about 200 staffers Wednesday morning. "Arms control,
verification, compliance, and nonproliferation will no longer be starved for
resources; quite the contrary, these missions along with our political-military
efforts will be adequately resourced and well-staffed with first rate
professionals," she told her personnel. "The proven and time-tested
tools of arms control have been seriously underutilized, if not neglected, by
the United States, and nonproliferation efforts have at times lacked focus and
follow-through. This dysfunctional approach culminated in the 2005
reorganization." – The
Cable
Mark Halperin writes: Cancelling the F-22 Raptor, the most capable fighter plane ever produced, is yet another act in the tragedy of a nation that, bankrupting itself, embracing moral decline, and apologizing to its enemies, is losing the will to prevail. In pursuit of false prosperities that have failed even the economy, America for three presidencies and an entire generation has diminished its arsenals, unbalanced its military, and forgotten its genius for strategy. – Wall Street Journal
Iraq
Not far from the site Iraqis believe to be the biblical Ur, birthplace of Abraham, Nasiriya has a streak of eclecticism that infuses everything from its politics to its landscape. Much of the city is given to the indeterminate overlap of rural and urban, lots filled with soggy trash and cinder-block huts, interspersed with urbane islands where men don a coat and tie to sip tea at the outdoor Writers Cafe. Many of those men represent a stubborn secular current that once made Nasiriya a bastion of progressive thought. Yet even they concede that, today, power here is the preserve of religious Shiite parties, leaving secular groups with almost no say in politics in a city where the Iraqi Communist Party was founded in 1934. That has meant that two alliances will compete in the March 7 vote for the province’s 18 seats in the 325-member Parliament: Mr. Maliki’s State of Law Coalition and the fractious Iraqi National Alliance, which joins the rest of Iraq’s powerful Shiite factions, some of which faced off at gunpoint only a few years ago in Nasiriya’s streets. The two alliances control all 31 seats in the provincial council, elected in January 2009. – New York Times
A top Sunni lawmaker says that his party is back in the election, less than a week after saying he was pulling out of the race in protest. Saleh al-Mutlaq during a news conference on Thursday reversed his earlier position and said he would now allow his party to take part in the vote. He called on all Iraqis to go to participate in elections. Al-Mutlaq is himself banned from running in the vote by a committee vetting candidates for ties to Saddam Hussein's Baath party. He said he quit the party in the 70s, and last Saturday said he was pulling his entire list out of the election. He gave no reason for his sudden change in position, which had raised fears about a wider Sunni boycott – Associated Press
Americas
The human rights branch of the Organization of American States issued a blistering 300-page report Wednesday against Venezuela, saying that the oil-rich country run by President Hugo Chávez constrains free expression, the rights of its citizens to protest and the ability of opposition politicians to function. The report, compiled and written by the OAS's Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, reflects growing concern in the region over how one of the organization's member states is governed. The document holds legitimacy for human rights investigators and diplomats because it has the imprimatur of the commission, which is run independently from the OAS and largely free of its political machinations. "This is a professional report, and the commission has been progressively more critical about Chávez over the years," said Michael Shifter, an analyst who tracks Venezuela for the Inter-American Dialogue in Washington. "There's a growing sense of the greater risks of human rights abuses and authoritarianism in Venezuela." – Washington Post
Cuban President Raul Castro issued an unprecedented statement of regret Wednesday over the death of an imprisoned dissident after a lengthy hunger strike that has sparked condemnation in Washington and in European capitals. The Cuban leader blamed the United States for the death of Orlando Zapata Tamayo, but did not explain how Washington was responsible. "Raul Castro laments the death of Cuban prisoner Orlando Zapata Tamayo, who died after conducting a hunger strike," the Foreign Ministry said in a statement Wednesday, adding that any reports that the man was tortured or mistreated in prison were false. Mr. Zapata Tamayo launched the hunger strike to protest what he said were poor prison conditions on the island. "There are no torture victims, there have not been any torture victims, nor have there been any executions," the ministry quoted Mr. Castro as saying during a meeting with Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva that was closed to news media on the island. – Associated Press
Washington refused to endorse British claims to sovereignty over the Falkland Islands yesterday as the diplomatic row over oil drilling in the South Atlantic intensified in London, Buenos Aires and at the UN. Despite Britain’s close alliance with the US, the Obama Administration is determined not to be drawn into the issue. It has also declined to back Britain’s claim that oil exploration near the islands is sanctioned by international law, saying that the dispute is strictly a bilateral issue. Argentina appealed to the UN Secretary-General, Ban Ki Moon, last night to intervene in the dispute, a move Britain adamantly opposes. – Times of London
Cuban security forces rounded up political activists across the island yesterday to prevent protests at the funeral of a leading dissident who died after an 82-day hunger strike…That did not stop the Government cracking down on dissent. Elizardo Sánchez, spokesman for the outlawed Commission for Human Rights and National Reconciliation, said security forces had detained about 30 activists. “Some have also been held in their houses, without judicial warrant, to prevent people from going to the wake,” he said. – Times of London
Iran
After a mysterious delay and a public challenge by Tehran, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov appeared to backtrack on Russia's pledge to supply S-300 surface-to-air missile systems to Iran, telling Moscow's official state news agency on Wednesday that Russia "has never taken actions that could cause the destabilization of certain regions." "There are issues that need to be resolved before [the contract] is executed," he said, referring to a deal that was signed in 2005. "We hope that all countries supplying arms, and not only defensive ones but also those that are killing our peacekeepers, will treat this issue in the same way."…Lavrov's latest comments suggest Russia is considering canceling the contract altogether rather than be seen as supplying weapons to Iran as the world powers contemplate stricter sanctions against the Islamic Republic. The Iranians are losing patience and have begun to lash out at Russia in the press. – Babylon and Beyond
Rep. Michael McMahon (D-SI/Bklyn) yesterday introduced legislation that will sanction members of the Iranian government who engage in human rights abuses. “Iran cannot continue with its flagrant violations of its international responsibilities,” said Rep. McMahon.“These targeted sanctions are a clear sign to Iran that the world is watching them and that America supports the Iranian people who continue to fight for freedom and justice."The legislation is a companion bill to the legislation introduced in the Senate by Senators John McCain (R-AZ) and Joseph Lieberman (I-CT). The measure requires President Obama to maintain a public list of names of Iranians who have perpetrated human rights abuses against Iranian citizens since the country’s presidential election on June 12, 2009. Individuals on the list will be subject to targeted sanctions, including a visa ban and financial restrictions. - Examiner
Korean Peninsula
North Korea threatened to attack South Korean and U.S. forces for scheduled joint military drills in March even as nuclear envoys picked up the pace of work to get stalled disarmament talks back on track. South Korea and the United States have held the drills for years without major incident. North Korea regularly criticizes the exercises as a prelude to invasion and nuclear war. The drills run from March 8 to 18. A spokesman for the North's army said the military drills by the South and United States troops were "nuclear war exercises aimed to preempt a surprise attack on the (North)", despite assurance by the two allies that they were purely defensive. "If the U.S. imperialists and South Korean warmongers launch the joint military exercises for aggression, ignoring our repeated warnings, we will react to them with our powerful military counteraction, and if necessary, mercilessly destroy the bulwark of aggression by mobilizing all the offensive and defensive means including nuclear deterrent," the spokesman said. – Reuters
Christian Whiton writes: While it is fine to keep open a diplomatic path to Pyongyang, inter-governmental discussions alone have accomplished little during the years Kim has ruled North Korea. These should be supplemented with measures that will expedite the regime decay taking place in the North–aiding the change that must come from within. First among these should be greater support for the independent media organizations focused on North Korea. Cultural exchanges that bring more North Koreans out of their country will help open more eyes still. Pacific democracies including Japan and the United States should open missions in Pyongyang–but only on the condition that any North Korean may access them, and that anyone issued a visa will be given permission to exit the country. Existing foreign missions in Pyongyang should make this demand or depart. – The Diplomat
Middle East
The son of one of Hamas's founders says in a new book that he served as a top informant for Israel for more than a decade, providing top-secret intelligence that helped prevent dozens of suicide bombings and other attacks against Israelis. Mosab Hassan Yousef's memoir, "Son of Hamas," is being published next week in the United States, and highlights of the book and an interview with the author appeared Wednesday in Israel's Haaretz daily. Yousef declined to comment, but his Facebook page plugs the book as "a gripping account of terror, betrayal, political intrigue, and unthinkable choices." – Washington Post
Respected worldwide, winner of the Nobel Peace Prize and for 12 years the leader of the U.N. nuclear watchdog, Mohammed ElBaradei is positioning himself as a force for change in his homeland. He has already said he might run for president of Egypt, and now he's forming a coalition to press for free and fair elections in a land ruled for nearly 30 years by President Hosni Mubarak. ElBaradei, 67, returned to Cairo only days ago to a hero's welcome by supporters who see him as the most credible opposition leader to emerge as this U.S.-allied country prepares for the 2011 presidential vote. Existing restrictions make it practically impossible for independents to run, meaning that ElBaradei's chances are dim without long-sought constitutional amendments. The former Egyptian diplomat has been mum about potential plans to join the campaign, saying that he would only do so if guaranteed that elections would be free, fully supervised by the judiciary and monitored by the international community. – Associated Press
The struggle between the secular Turkish military and the Islamic-oriented government reached new heights Wednesday as a court jailed seven senior officers —including four admirals, an army general and two staff colonels. The officers are charged with plotting several years ago to topple the government of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan. More officers could be charged later Wednesday. Former chiefs of Air Force, Navy and Special Forces were also among about 50 officers detained by police in a sweep Monday. Turkey, a predominantly Muslim but officially secular country, is witnessing an unprecedented showdown between the country's rising political Islamic movement and its fiercely secular founders, the military officers… The struggle is bitter and the way forward isn't clear. "The way to emerge from this crisis and conflict is to go to the polls," said Devlet Bahceli, head of the opposition Nationalist Action Party. For now, general elections are scheduled for 2011. The government crackdown has angered opposition parties and could deprive Mr. Erdogan of their support in overhauling the Constitution—a legacy of a 1980 military coup—to expand free speech and individual rights in Turkey. The current tensions have damaged the government's search for a wide consensus on the matter. "The government has lost the momentum for the Constitution amendment," said Rusen Cakir, a political analyst for the NTV and CNBCE televisions. "I think grounds for an early election have materialized." – Associated Press
Europe/Russia
Viktor Yanukovych was inaugurated as Ukraine's president Thursday, five years after his first bid failed amid massive protests over vote fraud. Mr. Yanukovych took the oath of office in the Verkhovna Rada, the Ukrainian parliament that has been the scene of intense maneuvering over the future of his rival Yulia Tymoshenko, who aims to stay on as prime minister…Weeks of negotiations in the back rooms of parliament have failed to produce a coalition against Ms. Tymoshenko. On the eve of Mr. Yanukovych's inauguration, she appeared to taunt his Party of Regions for this failure, challenging its leadership to oust her if they could. "The Party of Regions does not have the votes to carry out this dismissal," Ms. Tymoshenko told a government meeting Wednesday, appearing in a stark red dress instead of the soft tones she is known for wearing. – Associated Press
Four of Russia’s wealthiest businessmen were criticized by Prime Minister Vladimir V. Putin on Wednesday, accused of failing to properly invest in the country’s energy sector. Presiding over a meeting on the electricity industry, Mr. Putin said in a televised speech that the executives, known as oligarchs, had undertaken to invest in power plants some years back but were now trying to renege on the obligations, citing diminished demand for electricity. Mr. Putin said the investments were still needed, as demand would grow eventually, and that the men had committed to making them and should follow through. “We were counting on the owners being responsible,” Mr. Putin said. “Unfortunately, far from all of them showed responsibility.” While the comments were hardly searing, anytime Mr. Putin publicly criticizes a businessman it is closely watched and parsed by the markets. In Russia, the consequences of falling from favor are great in an economy with weak property rights and a recent history of effective nationalizations. – New York Times
SIGN UP
Sign up to receive FPI emails, including the FPI Overnight Brief, a concise daily compendium of essential foreign policy information and analysis.
Featured Video
Follow FPI
FPI is Reading
AfPak Channel on Foreign Policy
AsiaEye from Project 2049
Breitbart
AEI Center for Defense Studies
Contentions
Critical Threats Project from AEI
Democracy Digest Bulletin
Drudge Report
The Enterprise Blog
The Foundry
Foreign Affairs
Institute for the Study of War
Josh Rogin’s The Cable
Long War Journal
The Majlis
Mike Allen’s Playbook
National Review’s The Corner
The New Republic's Entanglements
One Free Korea
Policy Review
Politico’s Arena
Project on Middle East Democracy
RFE/RL’s blogs
RealClearPolitics
RealClearWorld
Laura Rozen on Foreign Policy
Shadow Government
Small Wars Journal
Wall Street Journal’s Opinion Journal
Washington Post PostPartisan
Weekly Standard
World Affairs